Any progess on the Recovery Color Shift...

Hello,

I have a 5D MkII and am experiencing a color shift when I use the recovery slider, LR 2.4.

I also use DNG color profiles that I have created.

Is there any fix in sight for this?

This slider really gets used a lot for images with a lot of dynamic range.

Thanks

Any progess on the Recovery Color Shift...

Can you please post an example .CR2 raw file that shows the issue? You can

use YouSendIt.com with target email address madmanchan2000@yahoo.com.

Thanks.

I have a 5D MkII and am experiencing a color shift when I use the recovery

slider, LR 2.4.

?/p>

I also use DNG color profiles that I have created.

?/p>

Is there any fix in sight for this?

?/p>

This slider really gets used a lot for images with a lot of dynamic range.

?/p>

Thanks

Any progess on the Recovery Color Shift...

If it is similar to the problem discussed here, than it is unfortunately a consequence of the way the dng profiles work. They have inherent hue shifts. You can ''fix'' the profiles using a tool that somebody wrote that is linked to at the end of the thread that I linked to that will make the shift not happen but causes other issues.

Thanks for your replies.

I am travelling right now and will show a before %26amp; after example when I can.?(I don't see how the raw file would show anything as you are saying the dng profile is at fault)

I am experiencing the same issue as in the thread.?The mid tones go towards magenta as the recovery slider is slid right.

This did not happen with the 5D, but I was not using LR 2.4 with the 5D.

Don't understand why this is happening and wondering if this will be in the cracks for a long time or if it is being worked on by Adobe?

Read the bit about ''twisted'' profiles, but to be honest is was a bit technical and on the fringe for me and photo processing.

Jao vdL wrote:

If it is similar to the problem discussed here, than it is unfortunately a consequence of the way the dng profiles work. They have inherent hue shifts. You can ''fix'' the profiles using a tool that somebody wrote that is linked to at the end of the thread that I linked to that will make the shift not happen but causes other issues.

I find they sometimes give unpleasant shadow color rendering. Otherwise they

work fine indeed.

2009/8/16 Dorin Nicolaescu-Mustea钁茶啲 %26lt;forums@adobe.com

I get colour shifts using Nikon NEF and DNG files I don't think it is related to just DNG's. I guessed it was just the way the slider worked, it looks like it may recover the RGB channels separately and depending on how far each channel is blown out depends on the recovery rate, hence a colour shift. I didn't have this problem in Aperture mind.

Ah,. well that explains that then doesn't it!!

I found this out 3 days ago and wondered what the...??

Original Canon 5D, LR 2.4, color managed screen.

When i get back to my computer i will endevour to send an example.